Aluminium 5083 stiff enough for electronic keyboard enclosure?

0
S
3

I’m working on an enclosure for a compact electronic keyboard system, including a weighted key mechanism, and have chosen Aluminium 5083 for all parts due to its corrosion resistance and machinability. My main concern is whether it provides sufficient stiffness to handle the mechanical loads and vibrations from the key mechanism without excessive deflection. Question to the community –would you consider Aluminium 5083 appropriate for this application, or would a material like steel or stainless steel be worth the additional weight and cost for improved rigidity?

    • B

      Aluminium 5083 should work well in keeping the weight low for your enclosure. However, if stiffness is more critical, steel would provide better rigidity, though it would significantly increase the weight, by 2 or 3 times.

      Alternatively, a hybrid design—using Aluminium for the outer panels and plated mild steel for some internal structural elements – could strike a good balance between weight and stiffness.

      0
      Reply
    • o

      If you want a stronger aluminum, you could consider also the 6XXX series: 6061, 6082.

      Depending on the corrosion environment, another good choice would be 7075 with a good coating. For example, in salt environments, the 7075 is not a good choice due to Cu content of ~2%.

      0
      Reply
    • 5083 aluminum has lower stiffness (elastic modulus ~70 GPa) compared to steel (~200 GPa), but offers advantages in weight, corrosion resistance, and machinability. For compact keyboards:

      Prioritize structural design validation: Topology optimization (e.g., reinforcing ribs, localized thickening) can compensate for stiffness and typically meet low-frequency mechanical load requirements.
      Vibration considerations: Use steel if key actuation frequencies align with the structure’s natural frequencies (due to steel’s higher damping), otherwise aluminum with vibration-damping pads suffices.
      Alternatives: 6061-T6 aluminum (slightly better strength/stiffness) or locally embedded steel bushings to balance performance and weight.
      Conclusion: 5083 aluminum is generally viable with optimized design. Steel is only necessary for high-frequency/high-impact loads. Finite element modal analysis is recommended for verification.

      0
      Reply
Aluminium 5083 stiff enough for electronic keyboard enclosure?
Your information:




Suggested Topics

Topic
Replies
Views
Activity
MJF material with the best low-temp resistance
Hello, I need to produce a small housing component for an outdoor sensor unit. I thought MJF could be a good fit for prototyping and potentially low-volume production. The part needs to handle exposure... read more
J
1
31
Apr 15
Best material for vibration-dampers fan spacers
Help, I need to reduce vibrations transmitted to the enclosure and improve airflow efficiency for 3D-printed spacers for mounting cooling fans on an industrial control cabinet. These spacers need to provide some damping without... read more
Y
C
2
78
Mar 20
Coated fasteners for stainless steel in coastal environments
We need to create a stainless steel structure for outdoor use in a coastal environment, and corrosion is our primary concern. We're considering coated fasteners but need to understand whether thicker coatings provide adequate... read more
M
C
1
93
Mar 18
Best injection molding plastic for plastic enclosure
Hi everyone, we’re talking about a snap-fit design for a small electronic enclosure that needs to be opened and closed frequently—about 20 cycles per week. The part should be injection molded, and I’m deciding... read more
M
B
V
3
143
Apr 16
Machining marks in hard anodized finish
I’m experimenting with hard anodizing for an aluminum part and trying to understand how the finish affects the surface. Specifically, does the coating fully mask machining marks, or are they still noticeable through the... read more
B
B
3
188
Feb 21