select
navigate
switch tabs
Esc close

Mesh accuracy concerns with FDM

0
M
3

I’m working on a small gear-driven mechanism for a camera panning rig and considering printing the 45° bevel gears in PETG (FDM). Tooth pitch is 1.5 mm, and the gears will be rotating slowly under low torque. My concern is whether layer lines and over-extrusion could cause poor meshing or increased backlash, especially since the gears need to run smoothly for accurate motion control. Would post-processing like sanding the teeth tips make a noticeable difference?

    • M

      I’m working on a small gear-driven mechanism for a camera panning rig and considering printing the 45° bevel gears in PETG (FDM). Tooth pitch is 1.5 mm, and the gears will be rotating slowly under low torque. My concern is whether layer lines and over-extrusion could cause poor meshing or increased backlash, especially since the gears need to run smoothly for accurate motion control. Would post-processing like sanding the teeth tips make a noticeable difference?

      0
    • n

      FDM-printed PETG gears can work for low-torque applications, but layer lines and minor over-extrusion will likely affect meshing smoothness. Since your gears have a fine, even small imperfections could introduce slight backlash or tightness. Light sanding of the tooth tips and flanks could help, but it’s hard to achieve perfect uniformity by hand. Have you considered printing a test pair and dry-running them to check for binding or excessive play?

      0
      Reply
      • M
        neil barnes

        I haven’t printed a test set yet—wanted to get some advice first. Would printing at a higher resolution (e.g., 0.1 mm layer height) or using a smaller nozzle (0.2 mm) improve tooth definition enough to reduce backlash? Also, if backlash is an issue, maybe I’ll add a spring-loaded tensioner. Would lubricating the gears (e.g., with silicone grease) help with layer-line friction?

        0
        Reply
      • n
        Massimiliano

        layer-line friction entirely. PETG’s slight flexibility might also introduce minor deflection under load. If smooth motion is critical, you might want to explore SLS (nylon) or MJF printing—these processes produce near-isotropic parts with tighter tolerances and no layer lines. That said, for a prototype or light-duty use, FDM could suffice with some trial-and-error tuning.

        In terms of lubricating, yes, light lubricant will reduce friction and noise from layer lines. Just avoid oils that might degrade PETG. A tensioner is a smart backup—let me know how the test goes! If you hit persistent issues, resin printing (for higher detail) or outsourcing to SLS could be next-step options. Good luck!

        0
        Reply
Mesh accuracy concerns with FDM
Your information:




Suggested Topics

Topic
Replies
Views
Activity
hidrogene turbine
I want you to make me two hulls of about 20 cm radius and a 16 cm rotor for a turbine that will burn hydrogen with oxygen.
0
4
Jun 05
Best way to mount NEMA 17 motor on 2 mm aluminum base?
I'm working on a compact test rig where I need to mount a NEMA 17 stepper motor onto a 2 mm thick aluminum sheet (EN AW-5754). The base has to stay as light as possible,... read more
T
r
2
52
Jun 03
Sheet metal hem
Hello, I'm trying to create a hem on the edge of steel sheets between 200mm and 400mm long. I can't find any manufacturer in France who can perform such bending/rolling/shaping with a radius of... read more
s
P
1
67
May 23
OD and ID vs OD and Wall Thickness – which is the best method of dimensioning?
Hello All, I am designing a conical-shaped plastic bushing and am confused if specifying the OD and the wall thickness is better for controlling the manufacturing process, or OD and ID separately, with their tolerance... read more
1
167
Apr 23
Metal 3D printing for watertight watch cases
Hi! I'm prototyping a watch case and considering metal laser sintering (DMLS or SLM) due to cost constraints—CNC machining is out of budget. My main concern is whether an as-printed sintered metal part will... read more
H
R
2
259
Mar 25