select
navigate
switch tabs
Esc close

CNC machining or 3D printing plastic part

0
G
4

hello! I want to manufacture small enclosures (electrical housing) that will be used in an outdoor application and need to meet IP67 standards for water and dust resistance (electrical housing). I’m evaluating whether to 3D print or CNC machine this part, considering material options and production volume (around 500 units annually). The design includes thin walls (around 1.5 mm) and precise snap-fit features. Would CNC machining or 3D printing offer better dimensional accuracy and surface finish for achieving a watertight seal, and are there specific materials you’d recommend for each process that is well-suited for outdoor durability?

Solved by Klemens Becker

 CNC machining an enclosure will be extremely expensive, you will basically be machining away most of the material from a solid billet of plastic. In addition to this, snap-fit components are usually quite small with undercuts that will be almost impossible to machine, especially with plastic. The thin walls you mentioned will also be difficult to achieve via machining. So I would definitely advise against CNC machining this part.

    • G

      hello! I want to manufacture small enclosures (electrical housing) that will be used in an outdoor application and need to meet IP67 standards for water and dust resistance (electrical housing). I’m evaluating whether to 3D print or CNC machine this part, considering material options and production volume (around 500 units annually). The design includes thin walls (around 1.5 mm) and precise snap-fit features. Would CNC machining or 3D printing offer better dimensional accuracy and surface finish for achieving a watertight seal, and are there specific materials you’d recommend for each process that is well-suited for outdoor durability?

      0
    • K

       CNC machining an enclosure will be extremely expensive, you will basically be machining away most of the material from a solid billet of plastic. In addition to this, snap-fit components are usually quite small with undercuts that will be almost impossible to machine, especially with plastic. The thin walls you mentioned will also be difficult to achieve via machining. So I would definitely advise against CNC machining this part.

      0
      Reply
      • G
        Klemens Becker

        Would a CNC machined part not have better tolerances considering I need to create a water and dust-tight seal?

        0
        Reply
      • K
        Gregory H

        The design of the part more than the surface finish will dictate its ability to resist dust and water ingress. Have a look online for standard enclosures and how they are designed.

        0
        Reply
    • Y

      3D printing is definitely the way to go, you will have to strategically place the snap joints so that the layer lines are not aligned with the direction of the applied force, or else they will break. You also need to choose a material that can work outdoors like PETG or ABS for example. The production volumes are also very achievable with modern 3D printers.

      0
      Reply
CNC machining or 3D printing plastic part
Your information:




Suggested Topics

Topic
Replies
Views
Activity
Material recommendation for axial guide replacement
Hello everyone, I'm replacing a broken axial guide component from a spindle assembly—this part sits on the Z-axis and connects the drill to the mounted machine frame. It failed during a milling op, likely... read more
B
0
11
Jun 16
hidrogene turbine
I want you to make me two hulls of about 20 cm radius and a 16 cm rotor for a turbine that will burn hydrogen with oxygen.
1
28
Jun 13
Best way to mount NEMA 17 motor on 2 mm aluminum base?
I'm working on a compact test rig where I need to mount a NEMA 17 stepper motor onto a 2 mm thick aluminum sheet (EN AW-5754). The base has to stay as light as possible,... read more
T
r
2
56
Jun 03
Sheet metal hem
Hello, I'm trying to create a hem on the edge of steel sheets between 200mm and 400mm long. I can't find any manufacturer in France who can perform such bending/rolling/shaping with a radius of... read more
s
P
1
65
May 23
Mesh accuracy concerns with FDM
I'm working on a small gear-driven mechanism for a camera panning rig and considering printing the 45° bevel gears in PETG (FDM). Tooth pitch is 1.5 mm, and the gears will be rotating slowly... read more
M
n
3
124
Apr 29