select
navigate
switch tabs
Esc close

Is it possible to print waterproof parts with SLS?

0
E
4

Hello, I am looking at printing a complex waterproof part using SLS technology, primarily due to the complexity of the part. This part will be used in a water system and it will be continuously exposed to water. So ultimately this part must be watertight. HDPE would have been the perfect material but it seems that 3D printing in HDPE is not common. Since we are using SLS, nylon seems to be the obvious choice, specifically nylon 12. So my question is, will this material and printing technology combination produce a part that is watertight, and if not, are there post processing methods for creating a watertight part?

Solved by Greg Paulsen

Hi, Emma.

You can make watertight SLS parts by paying special attention to the sealing surfaces. Typically wall thickness around ~2 mm will be watertight. Leaks most likely will be at the junction where you are sealing. E.g., where you may have a cap or gasket. This is because of the inherently rough surface area of SLS nylon. Here's what you can do:

  1. Design wise, mitigate sealing points to focus on specific areas. Try to have all sealing surfaces as circular vs. irregular, and don't have any weird T-joint seals because they're so tough to guarantee a seal. Make sure you have features like screws on the outside of the seal so you don't have to seal each screw hole. Seals should be given even pressure and be backed up by some sort of mechanical restraint (screws, caps, clips, etc.)
  2. Smooth the part and sealing surface:
    1. Easiest, but risky: Chemical vapor smooth will help give a smoother surface across the part. I'd do this even if I'm doing the other suggestions below.
    2. Expensive, but less risky: Post-machining, however, is the best way to get a sealable surface (you need to add extra material to your design and post machine away. 
    3. Tedious, but doable: Sand, epoxy fill, and sand again the sealing surfaces.
  3. Use multiple o-rings, if possible, with silicone grease to help fill the voids. If it's an irregular surface, use a silicone caulk.
  4. Test with a light submersion and water indicating strips (or just paper) on the inside.

I have made SLS parts hit IP69, which was 1 hr, 10-meter saltwater submersion. Don't worry about the hygroscopic nature of nylon for prototyping unless the total life of the product is underwater.

Thanks!

    • E

      Hello, I am looking at printing a complex waterproof part using SLS technology, primarily due to the complexity of the part. This part will be used in a water system and it will be continuously exposed to water. So ultimately this part must be watertight. HDPE would have been the perfect material but it seems that 3D printing in HDPE is not common. Since we are using SLS, nylon seems to be the obvious choice, specifically nylon 12. So my question is, will this material and printing technology combination produce a part that is watertight, and if not, are there post processing methods for creating a watertight part?

      0
    • J

      Hi Emma, the nature of the SLS printing process does not lend itself well to being watertight. This is because there will always be some space between fused particles making the parts slightly porous. On top of that, nylon is hygroscopic, i.e. it will absorb moisture over time. SLS is probably not the best option.

      0
      Reply
      • E
        James Smith

        Hi James, thanks for the response! That’s a pity seeing as we cannot achieve the complex part geometry with other additive techniques, we need to try and make SLS work, but I am open to suggestions?

        0
        Reply
    • Xometry Engineer

      Hi, Emma.

      You can make watertight SLS parts by paying special attention to the sealing surfaces. Typically wall thickness around ~2 mm will be watertight. Leaks most likely will be at the junction where you are sealing. E.g., where you may have a cap or gasket. This is because of the inherently rough surface area of SLS nylon. Here’s what you can do:

      1. Design wise, mitigate sealing points to focus on specific areas. Try to have all sealing surfaces as circular vs. irregular, and don’t have any weird T-joint seals because they’re so tough to guarantee a seal. Make sure you have features like screws on the outside of the seal so you don’t have to seal each screw hole. Seals should be given even pressure and be backed up by some sort of mechanical restraint (screws, caps, clips, etc.)
      2. Smooth the part and sealing surface:
        1. Easiest, but risky: Chemical vapor smooth will help give a smoother surface across the part. I’d do this even if I’m doing the other suggestions below.
        2. Expensive, but less risky: Post-machining, however, is the best way to get a sealable surface (you need to add extra material to your design and post machine away. 
        3. Tedious, but doable: Sand, epoxy fill, and sand again the sealing surfaces.
      3. Use multiple o-rings, if possible, with silicone grease to help fill the voids. If it’s an irregular surface, use a silicone caulk.
      4. Test with a light submersion and water indicating strips (or just paper) on the inside.

      I have made SLS parts hit IP69, which was 1 hr, 10-meter saltwater submersion. Don’t worry about the hygroscopic nature of nylon for prototyping unless the total life of the product is underwater.

      Thanks!

      0
      Reply
    • J
      Emma Thompson

      Hi Emma, there are definitely other options. For example, SLA (resin printing) can produce highly complex watertight parts. The one downside is that this process doesn’t use standard thermoplastics but instead makes use of photopolymers. Most common photopolymers do not have great mechanical properties, especially when compared to the nylons used in SLS printing. That’s not to say there aren’t high strength photopolymers out there, they are just more costly.

      0
      Reply
Is it possible to print waterproof parts with SLS?
Your information:




Suggested Topics

Topic
Replies
Views
Activity
Issues with polyurethane bonded rollers under load
Hi! Currently working on a small batch of U-groove guide rollers for a linear transfer system, and I'm using a soft polyurethane tread (around 85A Shore) bonded to aluminum hubs. The supplier estimates each... read more
P
A
4
20
Aug 19
Best fixture setup for milling and drilling mid-size batches of aluminum brackets?
Hi, I've got a batch of aluminum brackets that need to be drilled and milled on all sides with high repeatability. Has anyone designed a modular fixture system for parts like this to reduce... read more
h
a
4
32
Aug 14
Vacuum casting for snap-fits
I’m planning to use vacuum casting to produce about 50 housing units with integrated snap-fit features for an electronics prototype. The parts need to survive multiple assembly/disassembly cycles during testing. I’ve seen mixed opinions... read more
J
A
j
9
67
Aug 11
Choosing the Right Material for Injection Molding – What’s Your Go-To?
Hey everyone! I’m working on a few small-batch parts and weighing my options when it comes to materials for injection molding. I've used ABS and polypropylene in the past, but I'm curious—what materials do... read more
0
93
Jul 18
Feasibility of sharp internal corners in CNC-machined
I'm about to place a CNC machining order for a small ABS housing with some detailed features, but I’m unsure if the internal recess can be manufactured as designed. The model includes sharp internal... read more
J
e
M
2
150
Jul 09