select
navigate
switch tabs
Esc close

MJF material with the best low-temp resistance

0
J
4

Hello, I need to produce a small housing component for an outdoor sensor unit. I thought MJF could be a good fit for prototyping and potentially low-volume production. The part needs to handle exposure to sub-zero temperatures (down to -20 °C) without becoming brittle while retaining a bit of flexibility for snap-fit assembly. Among the available MJF materials, which one offers the best low-temperature performance combined with slight ductility?

    • J

      Hello, I need to produce a small housing component for an outdoor sensor unit. I thought MJF could be a good fit for prototyping and potentially low-volume production. The part needs to handle exposure to sub-zero temperatures (down to -20 °C) without becoming brittle while retaining a bit of flexibility for snap-fit assembly. Among the available MJF materials, which one offers the best low-temperature performance combined with slight ductility?

      0
    • Top Recommendation: HP 3D High Reusability PA 11
      Low-Temperature Toughness
      PA11’s molecular chain exhibits greater flexibility than PA12, delivering superior impact resistance at -20°C to prevent brittle fractures. Despite its higher glass transition temperature (~46°C) compared to PA12, empirical tests confirm retained ductility in subzero conditions.
      Snap-Fit Compatibility
      With 5-10% elongation at break, PA11 allows elastic deformation for snap-fit assemblies. While its yield strength (~45 MPa) is slightly lower than PA12, structural optimizations (e.g., reinforcing ribs) can compensate.
      Environmental Resistance
      Inherently moisture-resistant and UV-stable for outdoor use. For extreme weathering, post-process UV-protective coatings are recommended.
      Manufacturing Feasibility
      PA11 is fully compatible with MJF systems, achieving comparable dimensional accuracy (±0.3% tolerance) to PA12, ideal for intricate housing geometries.

      Alternative: TPU (Thermoplastic Polyurethane)
      Pros:
      Exceptional flexibility (>300% elongation at break), maintaining elasticity down to -40°C.
      Cons:
      Lower rigidity (Shore 80A-95A) may compromise structural load-bearing. Surface prone to dust adhesion; anti-fouling coatings are advised.

      Non-Recommended Materials
      PA12: Impact strength drops ~40% at -20°C; snap-fit joints risk fatigue failure.
      PA12 GB (Glass-Beefed): Glass fibers exacerbate brittleness in cold environments; only suitable for rigid, non-snap components.

      Validation Protocol
      Prototype Testing:
      Freeze PA11 snap-fit samples at -20°C for 24 hours, followed by:

      Impact testing (e.g., ASTM D256 Izod/drop weight).
      10+ snap assembly/disassembly cycles.
      Post-Processing:

      Vapor polishing for surface sealing.
      Annealing (80°C/2hr) to relieve residual stresses and enhance thermal stability.

      Conclusion: HP PA11 optimally balances low-temperature toughness and snap-fit functionality for MJF-printed housings. TPU is viable only if extreme flexibility outweighs rigidity requirements. Prioritize PA11 prototyping to validate performance under operational conditions.

      Let me know if you need further refinements! 😊

      0
      Reply
    • T

      Hello, I can offer some thoughts.  For MJF, your best bet would be MJF PA12 (Nylon 12)—it has excellent low-temperature toughness and retains some flexibility. It’s used for snap-fit enclosures and holds properties in cold environments. If you need even better impact resistance at -20°C, you might consider MJF PA11 (though it’s slightly less rigid).

      0
      Reply
      • J
        Theodore Carr

        Do you know how it compares to TPU in MJF for this application? What about glass-filled PA12? I’ve seen it listed as an MJF option—would that help with cold resistance?

        0
        Reply
      • T
        J Fisher

        MJF TPU would definitely be more flexible, but it’s too soft for a rigid housing—unless you’re going for a rubber-like overmold. PA12 strikes a good balance; its brittleness is more of an issue below -30°C. For snap-fits at -20°C, it should work fine if you add tolerance correctly (e.g., 1-2% strain limit). Glass-filled PA12 improves stiffness and heat resistance, but it’s more brittle in cold temps—avoid it for your use case. Stick with standard PA12 or PA11. If possible, print a test piece and cold-soak it to check snap-fit performance before committing to production.

        0
        Reply
MJF material with the best low-temp resistance
Your information:




Suggested Topics

Topic
Replies
Views
Activity
Effect of zinc flake coating thickness on bolt performance
In an automotive subframe project using M12 class 10.9 bolts, exposed to salt spray and vibration, I’m looking into zinc flake coatings for corrosion protection. Curious if doubling the coating thickness—from 8 µm to... read more
B
n
T
2
36
Jun 26
direct metal laser sintering
I need to obtain hole/channel sizes of 0.65 mm. will this be obtainable with a 40-60 layer thickness in tool steel?
j
1
45
Jun 13
SLA material for outdoor indicator lenses
hi,  I'm recreating two small indicator lenses for a 1980s motorcycle restoration. These need to be clear, UV-stable, and able to handle exposure to sun and rain long-term. I’m planning to go with SLA... read more
R
R
V
2
127
Jun 24
Steel Advice
HelloI would like to request a quote for cold cutting tools (no temperature problems). I usually work with high-speed steels, for their hardness and the relative ease of re-sharpening, but none is offered in... read more
m
P
1
116
Apr 30
Fuel-resistant material for 3D printing
Hi! I'm restoring an older two-stroke motorcycle and need to replace a worn-out venturi nozzle that draws in fuel-air mix. I’m considering having it 3D printed, but I’m unsure which material would best hold... read more
A
R
M
3
129
Jun 24