en – Global
Knowledge & Community
Search
K
Quote & source your parts
select
navigate
switch tabs
Esc close

Material recommendation for axial guide replacement

0
B
2

Hello everyone, I’m replacing a broken axial guide component from a spindle assembly—this part sits on the Z-axis and connects the drill to the mounted machine frame. It failed during a milling op, likely due to tensile stress and repeated shock loads. We’ve tested Formlabs Tough 2000 and Grey Pro in-house; Tough 2000 performed better in terms of elasticity and strength. I’ve prepared an STL file—any recommendations for a material and process that would match or outperform Tough 2000? Bonus if it handles fatigue well.

    • B

      Hello everyone, I’m replacing a broken axial guide component from a spindle assembly—this part sits on the Z-axis and connects the drill to the mounted machine frame. It failed during a milling op, likely due to tensile stress and repeated shock loads. We’ve tested Formlabs Tough 2000 and Grey Pro in-house; Tough 2000 performed better in terms of elasticity and strength. I’ve prepared an STL file—any recommendations for a material and process that would match or outperform Tough 2000? Bonus if it handles fatigue well.

      0
    • J

      It’s not easy to find something better than Formlabs Tough 2000, it’s a great resin. However, since you’re specifically asking for fatigue resistance and better elasticity performance, it’s possible that Tough 1500 is actually a better fit for your application. It is more similar to polypropylene than ABS and handles cyclic loading better than the Tough 2000.

      0
      Reply
      • m
        Jones Smith

        Just a stupid question – does it need to be printed? Is it not an option to machine it from ABS or polyprop? I can’t see your STL file – how complex or intricate is the part? Virgin machined material should have better fatigue resistance than an SLA-printed part. Any 3D printed part will have layer lines and risks having defects that may contribute to stress concentrations.

        If it has to be 3D printed, you could try skipping SLA entirely and go for Nylon 11 in a PBF (powder bed fusion) printer. It is known for its flexibility and fatigue resistance.

        0
        Reply
Material recommendation for axial guide replacement
Your information:




Suggested Topics

Topic
Replies
Views
Activity
H7/g6 fit – is it too tight for manual assembly?
Hi, I’m using a limits-and-fits guide to spec a bearing housing. I’m looking at an H7/g6 fit for a sliding location, but this is a field-repaired unit. If I go that tight, is some... read more
N
E
2
184
Apr 05
Improving heat-set insert retention in FDM-printed ABS brackets
Hey! I have FDM-printed ABS bracket for an industrial sensor mount that’s fixed to aluminum frame using M4 screws. The part sees light vibration and occasional re-torquing during maintenance. I’m considering switching from self-tapping... read more
B
L
1
254
Mar 19
stainless steel bolts with brass inserts for a plastic intake manifold
hello, I’m redesigning an intake manifold joint on an IC engine where the upper and lower manifolds are plastic, and the factory setup uses M6 class 8.8 screws threading directly into plastic bosses. The... read more
L
A
1
412
Feb 24
Selecting the Molding Process for a GSXR 1000 Half-handlebar
Hello, I am currently working on the design/manufacture of a half-handlebar for a sports motorcycle (GSXR 1000). What is the best type of process that I could establish for the manufacture of the handlebar... read more
2
406
Apr 05
Laser cutting pc panels for machine safety enclosures
Hi, I’m producing clear polycarbonate panels for a machine safety enclosure, cut from 4 mm sheet with small mounting holes and tight internal radii. Optical clarity and edge integrity matter more than cosmetics. From... read more
L
J
R
2
1.0k
Feb 20