3D printed vs injection molded snap-fits durability

0
T
2

Hi everyone, I want to use snap-fit joints for a 3D-printed enclosure that will be opened relatively frequently for battery replacement. I will be using ABS or PETG as I have read that they hold up well to cyclic loading. Can anyone provide insight into how 3D-printed snap joints compare to injection-molded ones, or should I explore alternative methods?

    • T

      Hi everyone, I want to use snap-fit joints for a 3D-printed enclosure that will be opened relatively frequently for battery replacement. I will be using ABS or PETG as I have read that they hold up well to cyclic loading. Can anyone provide insight into how 3D-printed snap joints compare to injection-molded ones, or should I explore alternative methods?

      0
    • k

      Hi Tom, ABS is a great choice as it’s tougher than other common materials like PLA and PETG. Nylon is also a good choice but not all printers are able to print it. There are empirical methods to calculate the exact dimensions of the snap-fit mechanism to ensure the maximum cycle life, all you need are the specific material properties of the ABS. These equations are for injection molded joints but should still apply for 3D printed joints, just don’t expect your 3D printed joints to last as long as injection molded ones. As an alternative, you can also explore using heat insert fittings so that you can screw the parts together because ultimately injection molded snap joints will always perform better than 3D-printed ones.

      0
      Reply
      • R
        klaus kolb

        Klaus gave some good insights, I just wanted to provide some tips to ensure a successful 3D printed joint. Make sure you print the part with the layers in line with the long axis of the cantilever snap joint, perpendicular layer lines are much weaker. Add filets on any sharp corners where the stress concentrations will be highest, i.e. on the base of the cantilever, and first print a prototype of your connection so that you can properly test it before printing the entire product.

        0
        Reply
3D printed vs injection molded snap-fits durability
Your information:




Suggested Topics

Topic
Replies
Views
Activity
Mechanical Technician Student
Hello, I am a mechanical technician student at the professional school of technology in Bochum. If you have anything interesting for the school program or for my future independence, I would be very interested.I... read more
P
3
54
Oct 07
3D printing in silicone
Hi everyone,  I am looking at developing a silicone product, specifically an armband for a certain sports watch brand. The design is quite complex and it seems as if 3D printing is the best... read more
E
D
B
J
6
121
Sep 30
CNC machining vs 3D printing parts
Hey everyone, I am trying to decide which of my parts should be machined and which 3D printed. I am leaning towards 3D printing primarily because it will be cheaper. But there is one... read more
D
K
J
D
6
231
Sep 30
There are customer requirement for proto parts, How I can produce with low cost, shorter lead time.
Plastic resin- PA6/6T The resin has high melting temperature around 380deg C. Do we have any other options like silicon molding, Hand molds, Aluminium molding? to manufacture proto samples with low cost, short lead time?  read more
j
2
306
Sep 05
Is it possible to print waterproof parts with SLS?
Hello, I am looking at printing a complex waterproof part using SLS technology, primarily due to the complexity of the part. This part will be used in a water system and it will be... read more
E
J
8
663
Aug 12