Switch 6061-T6 for 5052-H32 (bending), weight vs strength

0
K
2

Hi everyone –

I’m evaluating the feasibility of bending a 5 mm thick 6061-T6 aluminium sheet into tie-off points for tensioned stabilizing lines, considering a bending radius of 15 mm. Given the known challenges of bending 6061-T6 without compromising its strength, especially at critical points where the material is under tension, I’m contemplating switching to a 6 mm thick 5052-H32 sheet. This change aims to enhance bendability and durability but raises concerns about the weight impact. How significantly does bending with a 15 mm radius affect the structural integrity of 6061-T6, and does a transition to 5052-H32, considering its thickness, offer a balanced solution in terms of maintaining strength while managing weight considerations? 

Thank you in advance!

Solved by Greg Paulsen

6061-T6 is an excellent material with a high-performance strength-to-weight ratio, but it's not ideal for forming because it can crack in that condition and break at the bend. 5052-H32 is better suited for forming because of its higher fatigue strength and malleability. It will have different properties, so you may look into designing other features like gussets or putting a weld in at the joints for additional strength.

Even with a 3x radius to thickness this part may have risk and requires review if you choose to stay with 6061-T6. I recommend speaking with an Xometry team member once you have your quote in place so they can review the design and feedback.

    • K

      Hi everyone –

      I’m evaluating the feasibility of bending a 5 mm thick 6061-T6 aluminium sheet into tie-off points for tensioned stabilizing lines, considering a bending radius of 15 mm. Given the known challenges of bending 6061-T6 without compromising its strength, especially at critical points where the material is under tension, I’m contemplating switching to a 6 mm thick 5052-H32 sheet. This change aims to enhance bendability and durability but raises concerns about the weight impact. How significantly does bending with a 15 mm radius affect the structural integrity of 6061-T6, and does a transition to 5052-H32, considering its thickness, offer a balanced solution in terms of maintaining strength while managing weight considerations? 

      Thank you in advance!

      0
    • Xometry Engineer

      6061-T6 is an excellent material with a high-performance strength-to-weight ratio, but it’s not ideal for forming because it can crack in that condition and break at the bend. 5052-H32 is better suited for forming because of its higher fatigue strength and malleability. It will have different properties, so you may look into designing other features like gussets or putting a weld in at the joints for additional strength.

      Even with a 3x radius to thickness this part may have risk and requires review if you choose to stay with 6061-T6. I recommend speaking with an Xometry team member once you have your quote in place so they can review the design and feedback.

      0
      Reply
      • K
        Greg Paulsen

        Thank you!

        0
        Reply
Switch 6061-T6 for 5052-H32 (bending), weight vs strength
Your information:




Suggested Topics

Topic
Replies
Views
Activity
Draft angles for master model?
hi, I’m designing the master model for a silicone mold (for vacuum casting) and wondering about the necessity of incorporating draft angles. Is it always required to include draft angles in the design, or... read more
P
R
3
18
Jan 22
Is drawing needed for modeled threads?
Hello, I have a modeled anti-backlash lead screw shown in the image below:My question is: when the thread is already modeled in the CAD file, is it still necessary to include a detailed drawing... read more
P
2
26
Jan 17
Thread Production
Hello, I'm a design student in Hamburg. I need to produce threads of a specific size for my project. Can I request this from your company? I have no experience in thread production, and... read more
P
N
4
75
Dec 20
Design adjustments for workholding in CNC machining
Hi! I need advice on optimizing the design of a part that will be CNC machined for workholding. The part is an aluminum bracket with several cutouts, about 150 mm long and 50 mm... read more
T
A
6
95
Dec 10
Tolerance stack up question
Hi all, I’m new to the world of tolerance stack up and working on a snap-fit assembly with five injection-molded ABS components. In prototypes I’m encountering inconsistent engagement forces, likely due to tolerance accumulation... read more
F
1
84
Dec 05